Karma Musings

Simplified definitions of Karma include 'what goes around comes around' and 'jaisi karni, waisi bharni' (meaning: as you sow, so you reap)

We love stories that illustrate Karma. Such as stories about someone who cheats his brother to gain sole ownership of a huge business empire only to eventually end up a leper in some incognito alley or a story about the helpless old father who is abandoned by his kids but after a few years of suffering, suddenly chances upon fame and success and thereupon gets the opportunity to ignore his kids in return OR better still be the magnanimous forgiver.

This idea of there being a system in place, of cosmic justice seems to makes sense but does it also reflect on fact?

Often, when we encounter news of terrible tragedy befalling individuals, families or countries, I hear people exclaim "why them?!! they don't deserve this." I also notice that this does not lead to them questioning the concept of Karma. They are content with simply pushing it into the huge thought-balloon of the unexplained that floats in the sky along with other mystical objects.

The way I see things, I am inclined to believe that things happen totally at random. Sometimes, good things happen to bad people. Sometimes bad things happen to good people. Sometimes, good things happen to good people and bad things happen to bad people. (we all celebrate the idea of Karma during the latter 2 random occurrences, as if it is what always happens)

Alternatively, I hear people saying to one another "you just need to focus on gaining good karma"

The theory of Karma, in effect seems to be an extrapolation of the latent human weakness of seeking a transaction out of every interaction; a benefit in every relationship etc.

But since I see happenings as totally random, I don't see the sense in "gaining karma". Being good doesn't assure you that only good things will happen to you. Neither does being a devil, guarantee a mountain of misfortunes.

Question is, would you still see merit in being good, fair and generous if you found out that Karma is a myth? Why would you? You ask.

Well, I choose to be good, fair, generous and forgiving because it makes me feel good about myself. I have no expectation of the universe or even the people that I am kind to, to return the favour. And yet, I see more goodness in the world than bad. So, that's my choice.

If you don't see merit in generosity sans the promise of good karma; if you indeed find that you experience joy and long-lasting peace and happiness from being the bad guy, so be it. To each his own.


Comments

Anand N said…
You are right!

We have evolved to be both generous and to be selfish -- depending on the context and circumstance. This mix of altruism and selfishness is observed across biological creatures -- and is not a new feature of man or belief in Karma.

But there is one sense in which being good to others is a good long term strategy. This make other people (who regularly interact with us) to perceive us as trustworthy -- and that is a huge advantage for anyone!
meraj said…
@ Pooja, Totally with you...the concept of Karma, like that of Religion is a man-made means of justifying the randomness around. But, 'Randomness' by its nature cant be justified!!!

@ Anand Nair, a nice TED video on your first point:

http://www.ted.com/talks/frans_de_waal_do_animals_have_morals.html
Brown Weed said…
'I am inclined to believe that things happen totally at random'

really?
Brown Weed said…
ealier, i too used to think that things were random, but now i see causality everywhere. that doesn't mean things are pre-planned - there a huge difference.
Brown Weed said…
and there's also the question of conscience. at some point, you will reflect on your past..

finally one has to live and make peace with oneself. as you put it, in the end, it is only about feeling good, not just in the present, but in the long run.
Hemant Sharma said…
I liked your neutral approach to karma or non-karma. It requires a long discussion but to put it simply: You would notice that certain people always fall into similar situations all their lives. Now some ppl think of Karmas as some mythical phenomenon but nature has answer to everything and nature always tries to attain balance. So if you someone does good, it is balanced by good done to him/her and vice-versa. This discussion involves a lot more variables coz nothing is in seclusion and amalgamated.
Pooja Nair said…
Yes, i see your point acha, and sorry for the enormous delay in replying (in this space, i mean) I talk to you nearly everyday. but i have decided to become more regular on my blog now..
Pooja Nair said…
thanks for sharing your views. sorry for the insane delay in reply. but feel like replying to all comments since the past 1 year, all of a sudden. :p
Pooja Nair said…
yes, but Karma is about pre-planned destinies..that there is an account book being maintained in the cosmos that exactly determine what will become of you in this birth or the next.
i don't agree with that.
In smaller, daily matters involving people, of course causality exists. if you hit me today. i am going to think poorly of you, until you make up for it. but i am saying 'life' does not function like that...
thanks for sharing your views. and sorry about the insane delay in respsonding. :p
Pooja Nair said…
yes this aspect is purely individual. Conscience is a function of your own yardstick of what is right or wrong. for example stealing is wrong. and your conscience should kick in when you steal. however, the idea of stealing from the rich to feed the poor may not hurt the thieve's conscience ever...even though stealing is wrong. :)
Pooja Nair said…
i am on a replying spree all of a sudden. so am replying here too although we had live discussion on the subject and agreed to disagree right? :) thanks for sharing your views.. :)

Popular posts from this blog

Narendra Modi - protector of Hindutva?

The joke in stereotypes

Narendra Modi for PM? - No Thanks!